Revised guidance for health care workers treating Ebola patients will include using protective gear “with no skin showing,” a top federal health official said Sunday, as the Pentagon announced it was forming a team to assist medical staff in the U.S., if needed.
Dr. Anthony Fauci, head of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases at NIH, said those caring for an Ebola patient in Dallas were vulnerable because some of their skin was exposed.
In the wake of those events, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is working on revisions to safety protocols. Earlier ones, Dr. Fauci said, were based on a World Health Organization model in which care was given “in the field” — in more remote places, often outdoors, and without intensive training for health workers.
“So there were parts about that protocol that left vulnerability, parts of the skin that were open,” Dr. Fauci said.
The CDC guidance was expected as early as the weekend, but its release has been pushed back while it continues to go through review by experts and government officials.
Health officials had previously allowed hospitals some flexibility to use available covering when dealing with suspected Ebola patients. The new guidelines are expected to set a firmer standard: calling for full-body suits and hoods that protect worker’s necks, setting rigorous rules for removal of equipment and disinfection of hands, and calling for a “site manager” to supervise the putting on and taking off of equipment.
The guidelines are also expected to require a “buddy system,” in which workers check each other as they come in and go out. Hospital workers also will be expected to exhaustively practice getting in and out of the equipment. As Dr. Fauci explained, the type of care provided in U.S. hospitals is far more intensive than the care that can be provided in rural Africa, which increases the risk that workers will come into contact with contaminated fluids.
“Very clearly, when you go into a hospital, have to intubate somebody, have all of the body fluids, you’ve got to be completely covered. So that’s going to be one of the things … to be complete covering with no skin showing whatsoever,” said Dr. Fauci.
The American Nurses Association and other groups have called for better guidance that sets clearer standards on what kind of equipment, how to put it on and how to take it off. Pamela Cipriano, the association’s president, said she is “disappointed that the recommendations are still not available.”
New protocol will address shortcomings revealed in Dallas cases
The push to revise current protocol stems from the infection of two nurses at a Dallas hospital who treated an Ebola-infected patient named Thomas Eric Duncan — the first person diagnosed with the virus in the U.S.
The nurses, Nina Pham and Amber Joy Vinson, were diagnosed with Ebola less than a week later. Officials say how they were infected remains somewhat of a mystery.
Current CDC protocol for the use of personal protective equipment will be revised in response to the infection of two healthcare workers with the Ebola virus, officials said this weekend.
Duncan’s medical records, provided by his family to The Associated Press, show Pham first encountered the patient after he was moved to intensive care at 4:40 p.m. on Sept. 29, more than 30 hours after he came to the ER. Nearly 27 hours later, Vinson first appears in Duncan’s charts.
In Pham’s first entry, she makes no mention of protective gear — although doctors and nurses may not always note their own safeguards in medical records, since they are focused on logging the patient’s care. When she logged again the following morning, she mentioned wearing a double gown, face shield and protective footwear — equipment she mentioned again in later entries.
In the first apparent mention of Vinson, she is said to have worn personal protection, including a hazardous-materials suit and face shield. Hospital officials have said masks that cover the nose and mouth were optional, consistent with CDC guidelines at the time. The CDC later advised leg covers and isolation suits, and the hospital complied, Texas Health Presbyterian officials said.
Nurses have voiced concern that they have never cared for Ebola patients before and feel unprepared and underequipped. “If hospital administrators had to take care of Ebola patients, they would have the gold standard and hazmat suits,” said RoseAnn DeMoro, executive director of National Nurses United, a union with 185,000 members.
The CDC has published detailed guidelines on how to handle various aspects of Ebola–from lab specimens and infectious waste to the proper use of protective equipment–but how that information gets communicated to frontline workers varies widely. In some places that do have the suits, nurses have not practiced taking them on and off. “The hospital is sending them essentially a link to the CDC website. That’s not preparation. That’s like a do-it-yourself manual,” DeMoro said.
Vinson’s family issued a statement Sunday rejecting claims that the nurse had acted carelessly by flying from Dallas to Ohio, then back to Dallas, after treating Duncan. “Suggestions that she ignored any of the physician- and government-provided protocols recommended to her are patently untrue and hurtful,” the family wrote.
Emergency response teams ready for future cases
Also on Sunday, the Pentagon announced that Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel had ordered the formation of a 30-person support team from across the services to assist civilian medical professionals in the U.S. if needed to treat Ebola. So far, three cases have been confirmed in the U.S.
The team was to be formed by Northern Command’s Commander, Gen. Chuck Jacoby, and was to consist of 20 critical care nurses, five doctors trained in infectious disease and five trainers in infectious disease protocols. Once formed, the team would undergo up to a week of specialized training in infection control and personal protective equipment at Fort Sam Houston in San Antonio, Texas, then remain in “prepare to deploy” status for 30 days.
The team would not be sent to West Africa or other overseas location, and would “be called upon domestically only if deemed prudent by our public health professionals,” Pentagon press secretary Rear Adm. John Kirby said in a statement Sunday.
Ebola’s incubation period is 21 days, and Dr. Fauci noted that mark was reached Sunday for Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital workers who first treated Duncan. “The ones now today that are going to be ‘off the hook’ are the ones that saw him initially in the emergency room,” said Fauci, representing the Obama administration as he appeared on five Sunday news shows.
Duncan was seen at the hospital on Sept. 26 and sent home with antibiotics. He returned by ambulance and was admitted Sept. 28, and died of Ebola Oct. 8.
Judge Clay Jenkins, the chief executive of Dallas County, called the 75 health workers who cared for Duncan “hometown health care heroes,” and said they had signed agreements with the state’s public health commissioner to stay off public transportation.
He said if any other health workers test positive for Ebola, a plan is in place that includes the following protocols:
- All intake will be done at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital.
- Ambulances have been instructed to bring anyone with a history of West Africa travel and a fever to that hospital.
- Those found to be infected will be transferred by air ambulance to one of three national health centers set up to handle very risky germs, or by ground ambulance to the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston, which has the capability of disposing of the “copious waste” that Ebola cases generate.
- If a large number of cases surface, a triage unit at another, undisclosed location will be set up in the next 24 hours, with isolation units.